L.A. Noire - Upon Reflection
Genre: Crime
Director: Gavin O'Connor
Writer: John Malone
Cast: Joe Alwyn, Michael Mosley, Josh Charles, Brent Sexton, Katie Findlay, Gabriel Basso, Todd Stashwick
Plot: Plot: 1945 - The Battle of Okinawa. Exploding mortar shells kick earth up into the air as Cole Phelps (Joe Alwyn) and his fellow U.S. Marines begin trying to push through the enemy lines at Sugar Loaf Hill. A bunch of Japanese soldiers seemingly pop out of nowhere. Phelps tackles his friend Hank Merril (Gabriel Basso) out of the way and opens fires on the enemy combatants. In the fire fight, the rest of their battalion is killed, leaving just Phelps and Merril to fend for themselves. Phelps suggests they fall back, but Merril protests, citing their orders to continue pushing forward. They begin crawling forward through the tall grass to avoid detection, eventually stumbling upon a foxhole. Phelps says they need to rest. Merril digs through his pack for some provisions when suddenly he is ripped to shreds by an explosion. Cole looks on in shock, as pieces of Merril are scattered throughout the foxhole. Cole looks down at his hands and feels what has to be a piece of Merril's skull. Cole stares straight ahead. The next morning, a group of Marines find Cole sitting next to Merril's remains.
1947 - Los Angeles. Cole Phelps is now a police officer in Los Angeles. He is walking with his partner Officer Ralph Dunn (Michael Mosley) back to their squad car after getting a cup of coffee when they hear a call from dispatch over their radio. Dunn answers the call immediately. The dispatcher informs them of a shooting at 16th and Industrial Street and that the officers already on location are requesting uniform assistance for an evidence search. Dunn responds, telling the dispatcher they are on their way. Cole gets behind the wheel and begins driving towards the location. Cole speeds through the developing streets of Los Angeles, sirens blaring.
When Phelps and Dunn arrive, they see a body being placed in the coroner's van and being driven away. A Homicide Detective at the scene, Det. Floyd Rose (Josh Charles) asks if they are the backup. Cole responds in the affirmative and introduces himself and Dunn, saying they are from the Wilshire Precinct. Floyd then briefs them on the situation. He tells them that the victim was a black male named Scooter Peyton, who was shot in the alleyway and is on the way to the Central Morgue. Rose says that witnesses claim a tall Caucasian male shot Peyton twice in the head and then tossed his weapon before fleeing the scene. Floyd tells Dunn and Phelps that he's tasking them with finding the gun, since he could care less about the death of a lowlife like Peyton.
With their flash lights out, Phelps and Dunn search through the alleyway. Dunn freezes and aims his light at the sizable blood splatter on a nearby doorway. Phelps walks by the blood stain when suddenly he freezes. Something has caught his attention. Dunn asks him what it is, and Phelps points to an open window. Dunn is confused, thinking Phelps is suggesting the killer through the gun through it, saying that wouldn't be much of a place to hide a murder weapon. Phelps tells him to look in the reflection on the window, but Dunn doesn't notice anything. Phelps walks around a corner to a drainpipe and begins climbing it. Dunn is confused. Phelps climbs all the way up to the rooftop where he finds the gun. He then slides back down the drainpipe. Dunn demands to know what the hell Phelps was doing, when Phelps pulls the murder weapon out of his pocket. Dunn is excited and wants to turn the gun into the station, but Phelps suggests they try to get the name of the gun's owner first, and asks Dunn if there is a gun store nearby. Dunn says there's one just a couple of blocks away.
At the gun store, the gun owner remembers selling the gun, a Smith & Wesson Model 27. Phelps is surprised that the store owner would remember the weapon in particular, but the owner says that the grip was custom so it had to be special ordered. He tells them that the gun was purchased by Errol Schroeder. Dunn says they should call their findings in, but Phelps says they're not going to get any where in the department without showing initiative and insists they go pay Schroeder a visit.
When they arive at Schroeder's address, Phelps immediately hops out of the car and checks the apartment complex's directory for Schroeder's apartment number. Phelps and Dunn make their way up the complex's stairs and knock on the door. Errol Schroeder (Todd Stashwick) answers and demands to know what they want. They ask if he owns a Smith & Wesson Model 27. Schroeder confirms that he does. Phelps then informs him of the murder of Scooter Peyton. Schroeder does not seem surprised by this news, but insists that he didn't have anything to do with it. He tells them that his gun is safely tucked away in a drawer in his living room. He walks over to his drawer to show the officers that his gun is where he said it is. He opens the drawer, but finds the gun is missing. Phelps tells Schroeder that he is under arrest for the murder of Scooter Peyton. Schroeder tries to make a run for it, knocking Dunn to the floor. Phelps punches Schroeder, knocking him out. Phelps then cuffs Schroeder as he lays on the floor of his apartment.
With Schroeder cuffed on the floor, Phelps begins looking around the apartment for any other useful clues. In a dresser, Phelps finds a green notebook. Phelps begins to look through it and he determines it to be a list of bribes that have been given out, showing the name of each person and the amount given to them. Phelps scrolls through the list when he stops at the name Floyd Rose. Phelps asks if that was the name of the detective from the crime scene. Dunn confirms the information. Phelps wonders aloud if maybe Floyd had something to do with Scooter Peyton's death. Dunn tells him that such a question is way above their pay grade. Dunn says to call in their arrest of Errol Schroeder and leave the notebook where he found it. Phelps agrees, and places the notebook on top of the dresser.
Detective Rusty Galloway (Brent Sexton) arrives at the crime scene, relieving Phelps and Dunn. He thanks them for their diligent work, but tells them that he and his partner, Floyd Rose, will handle the case from here.
Phelps returns home to his small bungalow-style house in one of the many new housing developments on the outskirts of the city. He walks inside where he is greeted by his wife, Marie (Katie Findlay). She asks how work was, but he doesn't want to get into it, he just wants to get some sleep.
1947 - Los Angeles. Cole Phelps is now a police officer in Los Angeles. He is walking with his partner Officer Ralph Dunn (Michael Mosley) back to their squad car after getting a cup of coffee when they hear a call from dispatch over their radio. Dunn answers the call immediately. The dispatcher informs them of a shooting at 16th and Industrial Street and that the officers already on location are requesting uniform assistance for an evidence search. Dunn responds, telling the dispatcher they are on their way. Cole gets behind the wheel and begins driving towards the location. Cole speeds through the developing streets of Los Angeles, sirens blaring.
When Phelps and Dunn arrive, they see a body being placed in the coroner's van and being driven away. A Homicide Detective at the scene, Det. Floyd Rose (Josh Charles) asks if they are the backup. Cole responds in the affirmative and introduces himself and Dunn, saying they are from the Wilshire Precinct. Floyd then briefs them on the situation. He tells them that the victim was a black male named Scooter Peyton, who was shot in the alleyway and is on the way to the Central Morgue. Rose says that witnesses claim a tall Caucasian male shot Peyton twice in the head and then tossed his weapon before fleeing the scene. Floyd tells Dunn and Phelps that he's tasking them with finding the gun, since he could care less about the death of a lowlife like Peyton.
With their flash lights out, Phelps and Dunn search through the alleyway. Dunn freezes and aims his light at the sizable blood splatter on a nearby doorway. Phelps walks by the blood stain when suddenly he freezes. Something has caught his attention. Dunn asks him what it is, and Phelps points to an open window. Dunn is confused, thinking Phelps is suggesting the killer through the gun through it, saying that wouldn't be much of a place to hide a murder weapon. Phelps tells him to look in the reflection on the window, but Dunn doesn't notice anything. Phelps walks around a corner to a drainpipe and begins climbing it. Dunn is confused. Phelps climbs all the way up to the rooftop where he finds the gun. He then slides back down the drainpipe. Dunn demands to know what the hell Phelps was doing, when Phelps pulls the murder weapon out of his pocket. Dunn is excited and wants to turn the gun into the station, but Phelps suggests they try to get the name of the gun's owner first, and asks Dunn if there is a gun store nearby. Dunn says there's one just a couple of blocks away.
At the gun store, the gun owner remembers selling the gun, a Smith & Wesson Model 27. Phelps is surprised that the store owner would remember the weapon in particular, but the owner says that the grip was custom so it had to be special ordered. He tells them that the gun was purchased by Errol Schroeder. Dunn says they should call their findings in, but Phelps says they're not going to get any where in the department without showing initiative and insists they go pay Schroeder a visit.
When they arive at Schroeder's address, Phelps immediately hops out of the car and checks the apartment complex's directory for Schroeder's apartment number. Phelps and Dunn make their way up the complex's stairs and knock on the door. Errol Schroeder (Todd Stashwick) answers and demands to know what they want. They ask if he owns a Smith & Wesson Model 27. Schroeder confirms that he does. Phelps then informs him of the murder of Scooter Peyton. Schroeder does not seem surprised by this news, but insists that he didn't have anything to do with it. He tells them that his gun is safely tucked away in a drawer in his living room. He walks over to his drawer to show the officers that his gun is where he said it is. He opens the drawer, but finds the gun is missing. Phelps tells Schroeder that he is under arrest for the murder of Scooter Peyton. Schroeder tries to make a run for it, knocking Dunn to the floor. Phelps punches Schroeder, knocking him out. Phelps then cuffs Schroeder as he lays on the floor of his apartment.
With Schroeder cuffed on the floor, Phelps begins looking around the apartment for any other useful clues. In a dresser, Phelps finds a green notebook. Phelps begins to look through it and he determines it to be a list of bribes that have been given out, showing the name of each person and the amount given to them. Phelps scrolls through the list when he stops at the name Floyd Rose. Phelps asks if that was the name of the detective from the crime scene. Dunn confirms the information. Phelps wonders aloud if maybe Floyd had something to do with Scooter Peyton's death. Dunn tells him that such a question is way above their pay grade. Dunn says to call in their arrest of Errol Schroeder and leave the notebook where he found it. Phelps agrees, and places the notebook on top of the dresser.
Detective Rusty Galloway (Brent Sexton) arrives at the crime scene, relieving Phelps and Dunn. He thanks them for their diligent work, but tells them that he and his partner, Floyd Rose, will handle the case from here.
Phelps returns home to his small bungalow-style house in one of the many new housing developments on the outskirts of the city. He walks inside where he is greeted by his wife, Marie (Katie Findlay). She asks how work was, but he doesn't want to get into it, he just wants to get some sleep.
Just like John Malone's earlier work for the studio, you can sense there's a certain prestige to the series. From the unprecedent attention to detail to the immaculate writing, L.A. Noire has the word prestige written all over it.
I'll start by saying that I really enjoyed the overall pilot and I'm really excited about the series overall thanks to the talent involved, but it must be the nitpicker in me that feels like the investigation in the pilot could have been more interesting, because as the characters principal vehicle, it felt a little bland compared to the world and setting of the series.
I've always been a fan of period pieces and John Malone knows how to make one. In the crazy world of the 60's, the series has great production design and direction. I'd also like to point out the great ensemble cast formed by character actors who really work well together.